Magnus Carlsen is fighting to save his status as the world number one chess player and his 2800-plus rating after the 35-year-old Norwegian suffered a form collapse at the Total World Championship Pilot in Budapest. A run of 10 winless games, including a defeat against Armenia’s Haik Martirosyan, meant that Carlsen missed out on the semi-finals. Instead, he met Kazakhstan’s Bibisara Assaubayeva in a playoff for 17th to 20th places.
The poor run narrowed Carlsen’s cushion at the top of the world rankings. He had previously enjoyed a 40-point lead over his closest rivals, Fabiano Caruana and Hikaru Nakamura, but that margin was reduced to single figures. Caruana had only been closer during his world title match with Carlsen in London in 2018, when he drew all 12 classical games before losing a speed tie-break.
Carlsen rediscovered some form against Assaubayeva in the blitz and rapid sections. He chose to default their two fast classical games rather than risk a rating loss or draw over the board, which would have dropped him below 2800. His argument was that the matches were already decided, meaning the classical games should not be rated. Defaulting the fast classical game when the match was already decided has since spread to other matches. Meanwhile, Carlsen defeated Vladislav Artemiev in their Fast Classic game to lead 11-9 in the match for 17th and 18th places.
The tournament format caused controversy during the event. US grandmaster Wesley So was initially scathing on social media before later retracting his remarks. He wrote that if he had known the pilot format was going to be even half as bad, he would never have come. So added that playing eight games a day across different time controls for four days straight in the match stage was maximum absurdity.
The two Total World Championship finalists are Anish Giri of the Netherlands and Alireza Firouzja of France. Giri defeated France’s Maxime Vachier-Lagrave on both semi-final days, while Firouzja won an Armageddon decider against Caruana of the US. Giri won day one of the final 11-9, leaving Firouzja needing a win to force another Armageddon decider.
Chess champions do not normally decline in their mid-30s, making Carlsen’s slump unexpected after he had initially dominated the blitz tournament that launched the Budapest event earlier this month. The downturn leaves his position vulnerable ahead of his next event, the Super Rapidplay at the XTX Markets London Chess Classic. Opponents there will likely play with renewed ambition, knowing that even a half point against the world number one would mark a career milestone.
